POSTING & TOASTING

As always, POST CREDITS airs on Bloomberg TV Tuesdays at 6pm ET & 10pm ET, and full episodes go live on our YouTube channel at 6pm ET on Wednesdays: youtube.com/@postcreditstv
This week’s guest was Reza Izad, co-founder and co-CEO of Underscore Talent. He started at UTA, co-founded Studio71, and now runs a management company organized into departments for gaming, beauty and lifestyle, comedy, experts, STEM, sports and, increasingly, film and television. He has been in the room for most of the moments that turned YouTube from a hobby into a business, which makes him a good person to ask what comes after it.
Bigger than Eminem
Izad came into digital through IP, with no background in tech. In 2009, a colleague signed Fred, the high-pitched YouTube character with a huge kid audience, and Izad’s first reaction was to yell at him for it. Then he went home and checked Fred’s numbers against Eminem’s on YouTube. Fred was bigger.
What followed was a playbook that looks obvious today. They put out a Christmas novelty record straight to iTunes with no label. Then they co-financed a movie with producer Brian Robbins, screened it, and sold it to Nickelodeon, where it rated well. Studio71 and the MCN era came after that, and so did the stretch where Netflix pulled production in-house and independent opportunities dried up.
His view is that we’re now in version 2.0 of that original bet, and it’s a stronger one. YouTube is the dominant streaming service on the living-room TV, which means the people who make the best things there are now in demand from Netflix, Disney and Hulu as sources of original IP. He feels at home in this version because it looks like where he started.
A media business, not a job
The cleanest thing Izad said all episode was his answer to how creators differ from traditional talent. Dwayne Johnson is one of the biggest stars in the world, and he still depends on a studio system to build his projects, manage his brand and sell the product. A creator starts in a garage with an idea and very little money, and owns every piece of IP they make.
That changes what a manager is for. Izad’s managers work with people who already run a media business, so the job is content strategy, posting strategy, expanding to platforms where the client has no presence, and brand partnerships. His example of how deep that goes: paywalls and Substacks look like simple add-ons, but they’re e-commerce businesses with churn, and Netflix has something like 100 to 150 people working on that piece alone. Most representation firms barely think about it.
The most useful word in that business, he says, is “no.” A creator who can do everything has to decide what not to do, because there are only 24 hours in a day. The difference he sees between creators who reach the top and creators who stall is usually focus.
If you’re a CMO: the creator you’re pitching runs a company with its own plan. Bring a deal that fits the plan, and expect a no if it doesn’t.
Fame is the second step
I asked Izad how he defines fame now. Step one is the obvious one: people recognize you when you walk outside. Step two is where careers separate. Are third parties talking about you? Are you getting invited places because people want you there, and showing up in the US Open broadcast because a camera found you, not because you posted about it?
Plenty of creators have big, loyal audiences and never get that second step. The reason connects to something he said about algorithms. He doesn’t think they hurt quality. When YouTube started rewarding watch time, creators like Casey Neistat and David Dobrik figured out how to make longer videos worth sitting through. In his view, the algorithm decides what gets watched, and good creators work out how to make something great inside those rules. YouTube, TikTok and Instagram surface a lot of great work, and he pointed to comedy as proof: there are comics selling out clubs and theaters who never worked the traditional circuit, including Underscore client Zachariah Porter. The catch is that personalized feeds keep the best work inside its niche. If you’re into it, you’ll see it. If you aren’t, it never reaches you. PR is how someone breaks out of the niche and into the wider market.
His advice to traditional talent moving the other way was just as specific: stop treating social media as a diary and start treating it like a production. Podcasts work because they’re formats. Caleb Simpson’s “what do you pay in rent” videos work because the format is simple and his personality has room to play inside it. Izad thinks constraints help more than they hurt, and he had a great old-school example to prove it that I’ll let him tell you.
Must-See TV, minus the must
Here’s the original thought, and it comes from the most uncomfortable thing Izad said all hour.
I asked him who has the most power five years from now: the platforms, the consolidated studios, the management companies, or the talent. He picked the platforms, and his reason was blunt. If MrBeast quit YouTube tomorrow, Izad would bet YouTube’s viewership goes up anyway. There’d be some fuss and a few lost ad partnerships, and then the chart keeps going up and to the right.
Compare that to the network era. NBC could not afford to lose Friends or ER. Nobody today can afford to lose the NFL. In the old model, the hit show had leverage over the network because the network’s business depended on a handful of hits. YouTube doesn’t depend on any single creator, including the biggest one it has.
The numbers back him up. In Nielsen’s latest Gauge, YouTube took a record 15.8% of all US TV viewing in August, roughly double Netflix at 7.7% (Nielsen). And it got there without a must-see show. The share is spread across millions of channels, music videos, news, podcasts and how-tos, so no one channel is big enough to matter on its own. There’s a fair counterargument that minutes aren’t money. Puck pointed out this month that Netflix’s churn sits around 2% while peers average about 6%, and that people mostly turn to YouTube when they can’t find something to watch elsewhere (Puck). That’s true, and it doesn’t change the leverage math. The more viewing a platform holds without needing any one hit, the less any one hit can ask of it.
This is the same pattern I wrote about in “Cottage Industrialization”: lower barriers moved the gatekeeper from the studio to the platform, and the platform turned out to be a stronger gatekeeper because it never has to negotiate with anyone in particular.
So where does talent’s power come from? Izad ranks talent second, and I think he’s right, but the power works differently than it used to. A creator has very little leverage over YouTube. A creator has a lot of leverage over everyone else. MrBeast clearly held the cards with Amazon on Beast Games. The traditional studios and streamers need YouTube’s best people far more than YouTube does, which is why so much of Underscore’s growth is in theatrical, reality casting and formats that can travel. The value a creator can actually bargain with is whatever can leave the platform: the format, the IP, and the step-two fame that makes a buyer, a brand or a box office care.
He also pushed back on my Two Clocks frame, and fairly. I asked him whether he’d bet $100 on the content we make time for or the content we pass time with. His answer is worth hearing in full, but the short version is that you don’t doom-scroll YouTube. You press play, and the biggest channels show an early surge of viewing on every upload that looks a lot like appointment TV. I’d put it this way: YouTube has built appointment viewing inside an ambient platform, and it doesn’t need any single appointment to keep the lights on.
Four things to do about it
Buy a format that can move. When you back a creator, put your money behind a repeatable show with a clear structure. A format can move to TV, a streamer or a live tour. A post can’t.
Pay for step two. Budget for the PR and earned placements that move a creator out of their niche. The audience already knows them. Your target customer may not.
Stop treating YouTube like one channel. It’s 15.8% of TV viewing and nobody owns a piece of it big enough to matter alone. Plan it like a network made of thousands of shows, and pick the shows.
For your next staff meeting: list the creators you work with and ask which of them still has a business if their main platform changed the rules tomorrow. The ones who do are your long-term partners.
WHERE I’M GOING NEXT
CES (January 4-8, 2027, Las Vegas)
A note on what this is all about.
I spend most of my time at the intersection of where entertainment is going and where brands and creators are trying to get ahead of it; I’m fortunate enough to have seen a few cycles. POST CREDITS is where I think out loud about the power shifts, the deals, the platform moves, the cultural signals that most people notice too late.
Here’s where I manage your expectations: I publish when I have something worth saying. That’s usually once a week, sometimes twice when the news moves fast. No filler. If this lands in your inbox, it’s because I think it’s worth your time.
If you’re a CMO, a creator, a platform leader, or someone who invests in any of the above, you’re exactly who I’m writing this (and making this TV series) for.
Welcome.
— Ian
Feel like you’re more informed about the evolution of the creator and entertainment economies? Share this with your friends and colleagues.
Until next week,
Ian Schafer, Ensemble, and the POST CREDITS team.
